Free to read

Viva or thesis defense? The same exam, different names.

If your supervisor says “viva” and your handbook says “defense”, nothing has gone wrong. They are the same oral examination. What changes between countries is who sits in the room, whether you present first, and who is allowed to watch. What never changes is that you are defending research you did yourself, to people who have read it and are looking for where it gives way.

What it is called, and where

Viva voce, or just "the viva"

United Kingdom, Ireland, Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, Zimbabwe, Kenya, Nigeria, Ghana, India, Pakistan, Malaysia, Hong Kong

Latin for "by the living voice". Usually a closed room: you, two examiners, sometimes an independent chair. No audience, and often no presentation at all.

Thesis defense, or dissertation defense

United States, Canada

A committee of three to five, a presentation of twenty to forty minutes, and in many departments an audience of staff and other students for that first part.

Defensa de tesis, or defesa de tese

Spain, Portugal, Brazil, Mexico, Argentina, Chile, Colombia

Typically public and formal, with a tribunal of three to five and a presentation that is part of the assessment rather than a warm-up to it.

Soutenance de thèse

France, Belgium, francophone Africa

Public, with a jury and a presentation, followed by questioning that can run for two hours or more.

What actually differs

These are the differences worth knowing before you prepare, because they change what you should practise. The rest is local custom.

Who is in the room
Two examiners and often an independent chair in a viva; a committee of three to five almost everywhere else. One examiner in a UK-style viva comes from another institution and has no prior relationship with you at all.
Whether you present
A US-style sitting usually opens with a presentation that is itself assessed. A UK-style viva frequently has none: you sit down and the questioning begins.
Who may watch
Public in much of continental Europe and Latin America, and for the presentation portion in North America. Closed in the UK and Ireland.
How long it runs
One to three hours is the common range for a viva. Continental sittings often run longer, because the presentation and a formal jury statement are part of the event.
What comes out of it
Rarely a mark. Almost everywhere the outcome is a category: pass, pass with minor corrections, major corrections and resubmit, or a lower award.

What is the same wherever you sit it

  • You are defending research you did yourself, to people who have read it closely and are looking for where it gives way.
  • The questions come out of your own document: your methodology, your sample, your claims, the alternative you rejected. Not out of a syllabus.
  • A vague answer is followed up. Every format has some version of the examiner who does not accept the first answer and asks again.
  • You are expected to know the limits of your own work and to say so, rather than defend it past the point where it can be defended.
  • It is an oral examination. Knowing the answer, and being able to say it out loud under pressure to somebody waiting, are two different skills.

Thesis or dissertation: which word is which?

In the United States a thesis is usually the master’s document and a dissertation the doctoral one. In the United Kingdom it is frequently the other way round: a dissertation at master’s level, a thesis for the PhD. Both conventions are in use, plenty of departments follow neither, and the examination is the same either way. The word tells you which degree is being examined, not which kind of exam it is.

Do you get a score?

Almost never, and it surprises people who have spent years being marked. The outcome is a category: pass, pass with minor corrections, major corrections and resubmit, or a lower award. Minor corrections are the ordinary result for most candidates in most countries. They are not a failure and not a mark against you. They are the examiners saying the work holds, and that these points need tidying.

It is also why practice that ends with “you scored 78%” is preparing you for an exam that does not exist. A panel reaches a decision and says why. That is the thing worth rehearsing.

Practising for yours

Whichever name your institution uses, the preparation is the same: say your answers out loud, to someone who has read your work and will follow up when an answer is thin. Reading the likely questions is useful, and it is not the same thing.

The question bank is published in full, sorted by discipline, and free to read. The Full Defense is the sitting itself: a panel of examiners who have read your dissertation, question you out loud, and end with a decision rather than a score.

Reading is not rehearsal. Knowing the question is not the same as answering it out loud, to someone who has read your chapter and will not accept a vague answer.

Sit one before the day

Viva questions by discipline · Preparation guides · The seven phases of a viva